I attended a youth conference this weekend with the Evangelical Free Church denomination, and -SHOCKER- we never sang the song "Deep Cries Out."
Let me tell you, it was a breath of fresh air. I cannot remember attending another youth conference or camp in which that song was not used in worship time. I am a part of the Assemblies of God (AG), and they love to sing this song. Because of its wide-spread use within the AG, I have decided to tackle "Deep Cries Out" today.
There is a lot to like in the beat and catchy tune of "Deep Cries Out," so I can see why AG worship leaders frequently use it. Anyone who knows me well knows that I love Bethel Music, a band which includes the author of this song William Matthews. William is an incredibly talented musician who excels in ushering in the presence of God. He also happens to be downright hilarious. However, this song, which is probably his most well-known, is not my favorite.
 |
Worship leader William Matthews |
All too often, I see worship leaders using this song manipulatively because 1) it is accompanied by specific, choreographed actions that the congregation is expected to do and 2) contains many highly-exciting, emotional elements. Worship leaders may lead this song out of a concern that people don't seem "excited" enough for worship, and some even use "Deep Cries Out" to meet their own egotistical desires. Whether the decision to lead this song manipulatively is made consciously or not, those motives are wrong.
I choose to skip over this song when selecting worship sets, and I have good reason. To examine my reasoning, let's check out the lyrics of the song:
Verse 1:
I've got a river of living water
A fountain that never will run dry
It's open Heavens You're releasing
And we will never be denied
John 7:38-39 says, "'Whoever believes in me [Jesus], as Scripture has said, rivers of living water will flow from within them.' By this he meant the Spirit, whom those who believed in him were later to receive. Up to that time the Spirit had not been given, since Jesus had not yet been glorified." This notion of a flowing river of water coming from our acceptance of Christ and the indwelling of His Spirit is certainly Biblical. There is indeed "an open heaven" God is releasing as He willingly pours out His Spirit on all flesh.
Yet, I have a problem with the last sentence of the verse: "And we will never be denied." This is completely man-centered and theologically inaccurate. God gives us what He pleases according to His grace, not because we make loud, emotional demands of Him.
Pre-Chorus:
Cause we're stirring up deep deep wells
We're stirring up deep deep waters
We're going to dance in the river, dance in the river
Cause we're stirring up deep deep wells
We're stirring up deep deep waters
We're going to jump in the river
Jump in the river and everybody singing now
Again, this portion of the song is extremely man-centered as it's says "we're stirring up deep deep wells"; It eliminates God's choice completely by implying that people can force the Holy Spirit to move in whichever ways they please. The song then calls for people to respond with wild emotions in dancing and jumping as a result of the people stirring up "the water" themselves.
Chorus:
Deep cries out to deep cries out to
Deep cries out to deep cries out to
So we cry out to, we cry out to, You Jesus
Here lies my biggest problem with the song. The terminology "deep cries out to deep" comes from Psalm 42, so in that sense it is Biblical. Verses 6-7 say, "My soul is downcast within me; therefore I will remember you from the land of the Jordan, the heights of Hermon—from Mount Mizar. Deep calls to deep in the roar of your waterfalls; all your waves and breakers have swept over me."
The analogy of water used here is very different from the river of living water Jesus described in John 7. The entirety of Psalm 42 is a cry of anguish. Matthew Henry's Bible Commentary writes on these verses saying, "[The psalmist] was overpowered and overwhelmed with a deluge of grief... when the windows of heaven were opened and the fountains of the great deep were broken up." Henry goes on to say that the phrase "deeps cries out to deep" describes "one affliction [coming] upon the neck of another." Certainly we would want to cry out to Jesus if wave after wave of trials were flowing over us, but this is not the river of living water described previously the song. Would we dance, jump, and shout for joy in the waters of tribulation? I think not. The usage of this phrase in "Deep Cries Out" was taken out of Biblical context. Clearly, William used Biblical analogies of water in his song without taking them for their true meanings.
I've listened to Bill Johnson (lead pastor of Bethel Church where this song was created) speak about the concept behind this portion of "Deep Cries Out." He justified its use by saying that "deep cries out to deep" as used in Psalm 42 means that the depths of our hearts are crying out to the depths of God's heart. This is a nice concept, but it certainly isn't in context.
Bridge:
If He goes to the left then we'll go to the left
And if He goes to the right then we'll go to the right
We're going to jump jump jump jump in the river
Jump jump jump jump, everybody
If He goes to the left then we'll go to the left
And if He goes to the right then we'll go to the right
We're going to dance dance, dance dance in the river
Dance dance, dance dance, everybody
If He goes to the left then we'll go to the left
And if He goes to the left then we'll go to the right
We're going to shout shout shout shout in the river
Shout shout shout shout in the river, everybody
Certainly we want to follow Jesus wherever He leads us, whether that leads to good times or bad. But again, this seems to be taken out of Biblical context. If we are jumping into the deeps similar to those described in Psalm 42, would we dance and shout for joy? I think we would all have a much less hearty response.
I believe that there are essentially two aspects of congregational worship: communal and personal. The communal aspect of worship is that the body of Christ comes together as one to declare the truths of God. The personal aspect of worship is in each individual worshipping God of out his or her own spirit and drawing into a closer relationship with Him as a result.
I don't feel that this song fits either of those purposes. It is not a worship song at all because it is not declaring the truths of God in such a way that we'd draw closer to Him. It may fulfill a communal need to prepare and become "excited" for worship, but it is not a worship song in and of itself. If a communal "call to worship" is necessary at the beginning of a worship set, it can be done in other ways. I believe that our time spent in congregational worship should be just that– worship.
For these reasons, I choose to not lead worship with the song "Deep Cries Out." However, I will gladly serve on a worship team and sing or play this song out of service to my worship leader. There are some positives to this song and it can be led in a worshipful way, but overall I do not find it worthy of a worship set.
–Chloe